Top Red Flags When It Comes To Suppliers

The worst of the pandemic supply chain problems have waned but it’s smart to stay on top of your relationship with suppliers. Here are the key things to look out for.

What are some of the red flags from suppliers that CFOs should watch out for today? Amanda Russo, founder and CEO of Cornerstone Paradigm Consulting, based in New York City, shares insights and best practices for finance professionals.

Russo spoke with StrategicCFO360 about danger signs, how to handle them and how to maintain professionalism no matter how egregious the problem.

What are some red flags to watch for from suppliers?

One of the primary red flags to be wary of is the lack of transparency in pricing. When suppliers are evasive or unclear about their pricing structure and the breakdown of costs, it raises concerns about hidden expenses or questionable practices.

As a responsible manager, it is crucial to have a clear understanding of all costs involved and ensure that every line item on an invoice is explained comprehensively. By seeking specific clarifications and explanations, you can avoid unpleasant surprises and ensure transparency in your financial transactions.

Another red flag to watch for is unreliable communication and responsiveness from suppliers. Effective communication is the foundation of successful business relationships. When a supplier consistently fails to respond promptly, provide updates, or address concerns, it can lead to disruptions and delays in your operations.

Poor communication can cause misunderstandings, missed deadlines and ultimately impact customer satisfaction. When evaluating potential suppliers, pay close attention to their responsiveness and willingness to maintain open lines of communication. A supplier who values effective communication is more likely to be reliable and responsive to your needs.

Inconsistencies in quality or delivery are additional red flags that should not be ignored. Consistency is key when it comes to product quality and timely delivery. If you notice frequent inconsistencies or quality issues with a supplier’s products, it can harm your reputation and customer satisfaction.

Similarly, delayed or unreliable deliveries can disrupt your supply chain and impact your ability to meet customer demands. Regularly monitor the performance of your suppliers and track any recurring issues. If a supplier consistently fails to meet your quality or delivery requirements, it may be time to reconsider the relationship and explore alternative options.

How do you know when it’s time to end a supplier relationship?

Knowing when to end a supplier relationship is a challenging decision that should not be taken lightly. However, there are situations where it becomes necessary to sever ties with a supplier. Persistent ethical issues, such as fraud, bribery or labor rights violations, should raise immediate concerns.

Maintaining a strong ethical stance is crucial for the reputation and sustainability of your business. If a supplier’s actions conflict with your values and ethical standards, it may be best to terminate the relationship and seek an alternative supplier who aligns with your principles.

Contractual disputes and irreconcilable pricing issues can also be red flags indicating a need to reassess a supplier relationship. Disagreements over pricing or contractual terms can strain the partnership and hinder the smooth functioning of your business.

If efforts to resolve these issues through negotiation or mediation prove futile, it may be an indication that the supplier is not acting in your best interest. It may be time to consider having a logistics consultant or attorney review the contract to make sure you know the terms. Additionally, it may be necessary to explore other options. Consider working with suppliers who are willing to establish fair pricing structures and honor contractual obligations.

What’s the best way to have a breakup conversation with a supplier, without burning bridges?

While ending a supplier relationship can be challenging, it is essential to handle it professionally to minimize negative consequences and preserve future business opportunities. Before initiating a breakup conversation, ensure that you have a solid backup plan in place. Identify alternative suppliers who can fulfill your requirements and mitigate any disruptions to your operations.

Review your contract with the current supplier to understand the termination clauses and ensure compliance with the agreed-upon terms. Honesty and transparency are crucial before having a breakup conversation. Clearly communicate your reasons for ending the relationship and express your desire to maintain a professional posture. Even if you decide to never do business with them again, it is important to always channel professionalism over pride. 

What are some considerations/unintended consequences to be aware of when ending a supplier relationship?

Depending on what industry you are in, a lot of suppliers know each other, and in some countries, they have multiple names for one supplier. It’s a very common practice in countries with little regulation. Be careful how you go about severing this relationship and starting a new one; I suggest you should work with someone that can help you with this transition.

What are some green flags to look for when evaluating new suppliers?

Responsiveness, transparency, reputation and their willingness to earn your business.


  • Get the StrategicCFO360 Briefing

    Sign up today to get weekly access to the latest issues affecting CFOs in every industry
  • MORE INSIGHTS